The very tip of Staten Island - and of New York State - in ZIP 10307. A small town, historic, waterfront neighborhood with a real Main Street, beaches and a historic park at the edge of the water, and the end of the line calm you can only get out here. Here is what it is actually like to live here.
Tottenville is unlike anywhere else on Staten Island. This is the southernmost point of the island and of New York State, and it feels like it - a genuine small town with a Main Street, historic homes, and a tight knit community that has been here for generations. The housing stock is a real mix: old Victorians and historic single family homes alongside newer townhouse developments, so buyers get real range on style and price.
The water is everywhere out here. Conference House Park sits at the very tip, where the historic Billop House looks across the water toward New Jersey, and beaches line the edge of the neighborhood. It is quiet, it is calm, and it is the kind of place where people know their neighbors. The train starts its run here, and the Outerbridge Crossing to New Jersey is minutes away.
A historic waterfront park at the very tip, home to the Billop House - the spot where Staten Island meets New Jersey across the water.
Beaches and shoreline line the edge of the neighborhood, giving Tottenville a genuine coastal, small town feel.
A real small town Main Street - the kind of walkable, local center most NYC neighborhoods lost a long time ago.
Historic Victorians and older single family homes alongside newer townhouse developments - a genuine mix of style and price.
Tottenville is where the Staten Island Railway starts, running north to the St. George Ferry Terminal and the boat to Manhattan.
The Outerbridge Crossing to New Jersey is minutes away, making the trip off the island quick when you need it.
Tottenville is a distinctive, steady market, with a housing mix that runs wider than most South Shore neighborhoods. Most homes typically trade between about $550,000 and $850,000, with the number set by lot size, square footage, updates, whether the home is a historic single family or a newer townhouse, and how close you are to the water. Larger detached and prime waterfront adjacent homes sell above that range. Because the neighborhood's small town character and value draw steady interest, well priced, well presented homes here tend to move.
Those are ranges, not your number. The only way to know what a specific Tottenville home is worth today is a real read on the exact house and the most recent sales on its block.
Tottenville sits at the southernmost tip of Staten Island and of New York State - a small town, historic, waterfront neighborhood in ZIP 10307, known for Conference House Park and the historic Billop House, its waterfront and beaches, a genuine Main Street feel, a mix of historic homes and newer townhouses, and its quiet, tight knit, end of the line calm.
Most homes typically trade between about $550,000 and $850,000 depending on size, lot, condition, and home type, with historic single family homes and newer townhouse developments both in the mix. For a current price on a specific home, request a free valuation.
It is one of the most distinctive, small town neighborhoods on Staten Island. Residents value the quiet, tight knit community, the historic Main Street feel, the waterfront and Conference House Park, and the calm that comes with living at the very end of the line.
Tottenville is the southern terminus of the Staten Island Railway, so the train runs north from here to the St. George Ferry Terminal for the ferry to Lower Manhattan. Drivers reach the Outerbridge Crossing to New Jersey within minutes.
I grew up working this market. Whether you are pricing your home or chasing the right one, let's talk about your block specifically.